Muh. Zuhri


The aim of the article is to trace the development of the Western scholar’s studies on hadith as the second of Islamic sources. It started from the eighteenth century, and was an implication of their study on Islamic history, legal and theology. The most central problem associated with Prophetic hadith has undoubtedly been their authenticity. This issue occupied Muslim specialists since the early classical period. The first generation of Western scholars inclined to doubt the hadith authenticity, and then, followed by the next generation to convince that hadiths are forged. One of the ultimate theories to prove the hadith authenticity is “Common Link” theory, that hadith is originated from the common link figure, not the prior, moreover the Prophet. There are two or three generations from the figure to the Prophet. However, there is a scholar’s tent to refuse the previous research result on hadith, approving Muslim scholars opinion that most hadiths have been real event of what the Prophet did and said. They demonstrate some evidence by having some research results as the previous generation did.


Western scholar; skeptic; hadith; authenticity;

Full Text:



Amin, Kamaruddin. 2005. The Reliability of the Traditional Science of Hadith. Jurnal Al Jami’ah. Vol. 43, No. 2.

Amin, Kamaruddin. 2008. Muslim Western Scholarship of Hadith and Western Scholar Reaction: A Study on Fuat Sezgin’s Approach to Hadith Scholarship. Jurnal Al Jami’ah. Vol. 46, No 2.

Abbot, Nabia. 1967. Studies in Arabic Literary Papyri. Vol.II. Chicago: Qur’anic Commentary and Tradition.

Brown, Jonathan W. Tt. The Authenticity Question: Western Debates over the Historical Reliability of Prophetic Tradition.

Falahi, Ghulam Nabi. Tt. Development of Hadith: A Concise Introduction of Early Hadith Literature. UK: Islamic Mission.

Hallaq, Wael B. 1999. The authenticity of Prophetic Hadith: A Pseudo-problem Courtesy: Studia Islamica. Canada: Mc Gill University.

Hallaq, Wael B. 2005. The Origins and Evolution of Islamic Law. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Juynboll. 1996. Studies on The Origins and Uses of Islamic Hadith. USA: Ashgate.

Juynboll. 1985. Muslim Tradition, Studies in Chronology, Provenance and Authorship of Early Hadith. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Kizil, Fatma. Tt. In Pursuit of Common Paradigm: Islamic and Western Hadith Studies. Turkey: Yalova University Press.

Motzki, Harald. Whither Hadith Studies? A Critical examination of G.H.A. Juynboll’s Nafi’ the Mawla of Ibnu Umar and his Position in Muslim Hadith Literature. University of Nijmegen, Netherlands.

Motzki‚ Harald. 2005. Dating Muslim Traditions. A Survey. Arabica.

Robson, J. 1955. The Isnad in Muslim Tradition. Glasgov University Oriental Society Transaction.

Siddiqi, Zubery Muhammad. 1939. Hadits Literature. Dairat al Ma’arif. Hyderabad.

www. Askanislamicist. Wordpress. com.



  • There are currently no refbacks.