Indonesia’s Constitutional Identity: A Comparative Study of Islamic Constitutionalism

Novendri Mohamad Nggilu, Wahidullah Wahidullah, Evi Noviawati, Dian Ekawaty Ismail

Abstract


Constitutionalism in Muslim-majority countries faces the challenge of balancing the application of Islamic principles with modern values in the context of the nation-state. This research aims to analyse how Indonesia’s constitutional identity, based on the pluralistic Pancasila, differs from other Muslim-majority countries such as Egypt, Pakistan, and Iran, emphasising Sharia as the foundation of law. Using statutory, historical, and comparative approaches, this research finds that the Indonesian model creates a unique harmony between religious pluralism and Islamic values, different from the dominant theocratic. The novelty of this article is its comparative analysis of constitutional identities in Muslim-majority countries, particularly emphasising Indonesia's unique pluralistic model. In contrast to Egypt, Pakistan, and Iran, which incorporate Islamic principles to varying extents, Indonesia adopts a Pancasila-based approach that integrates religious values within an inclusive, pluralistic framework. This model illustrates how religious values coexist with democratic principles and human rights. The study positions Indonesia as a potential model for balancing nationalism, religious diversity, and modern legal frameworks, providing valuable lessons for other Muslim-majority countries facing similar challenges.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Abdurrachman Satrio. “The Existence of the Unamendable Provision of the Unitary State of the Republic of Indonesia: The Role of the Constitutional Court.” Comparative Constitutional and Administrative Law Quarterly 3, no. 4 (2017): 18–37.

Achmad Fauzi. Pancasila Ditinjau Dari Aspek Historis, Segi Yuridis Konstitusional Dan Segi Filosofis. Malang: Lembaga Penerbitan Universitas Brawijaya, 1981.

Ahmad Basarah. “Eksistensi Pancasila Sebagai Tolak Ukur Dalam Pengujian Undang-Undang Terhadap Undang-Undang Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia Tahun 1945 Di Mahkamah Konstitusi: Kajian Perspektif Filsafat Hukum Dan Ketatanegaraan.” Diponegoro University, 2016.

Ahmad Nurozi. “Comparative Study of the Process of Islamic Law Legislation in Indonesia with Malaysia and Its Implementation into Legislation Regulations.” Jurnal Hukum Islam 20, no. 1 (June 23, 2022): 125–54. https://doi.org/10.28918/jhi.v20i1.5906.

Ahmed, Dawood, and Muhammad Zubair Abbasi. Democracy Under God: Constitutions, Islam and Human Rights in the Muslim World. 1st ed. Cambridge University Press, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781316662618.

Ahmed, Zahid Shahab. “Islam and the Politics of Secularism in Pakistan.” Religions 14, no. 3 (March 19, 2023): 416. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel14030416.

Albert, Richard. Constitutional Amendments: Making, Breaking, and Changing Constitutions. Oxford, United Kingdom ; New York: Oxford University Press, 2019.

Ali, Shaheen Sardar, Arjumand Bano Kazmi, and Ashraf Kunnummal. “Do Adjectives Matter? Exploring the ‘Islamic’ in Constitutions and Constitutionalism(s).” Arab Law Quarterly 38, no. 4 (April 8, 2024): 466–501. https://doi.org/10.1163/15730255-bja10160.

Arabzai, Safiullah, Fazal Hadi Fazli, and Bashir Ahmad Mohammadi. “The Rights of Religious Minorities in International Legal Documents and Islamic Shariah.” American Journal of Law and Political Science 2, no. 3 (August 5, 2023): 24–31. https://doi.org/10.58425/ajlps.v2i3.194.

Arief Hidayat. “Negara Hukum Berwatak Pancasila.” Peningkatan Pemahaman Hak Konstitusional Warga Negara Bagi Asosiasi Dosen Pancasila Dan Kewarganegaraan (ADPK) & Asosiasi Profesi Pendidikan Pancasila Dan Kewarganegaraan Indonesia (AP3KnI), August 21, 2017.

Arizona, Yance. “The Return of Pancasila: Political and Legal Rhetoric Against Transnational Islamist Imposition.” Constitutional Review 5, no. 1 (May 31, 2019): 164. https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev516.

Arjomand, Said Amir. “Constitution-Making in Islamic Iran: The Impact of Theocracy on the Legal Order of a Nation-State.” In History and Power in the Study of Law, edited by June Starr and Jane F. Collier, 113–28. Cornell University Press, 2018. https://doi.org/10.7591/9781501723322-007.

Arjomand, Saïd Amir. “The 1906-07 Iranian Constitution and the Constitutional Debate on Islam.” Journal of Persianate Studies 5, no. 2 (2012): 152–74. https://doi.org/10.1163/18747167-12341242.

Asim, Muhammad. “Iranian Constitution Under Pro-Center Dogmatic Authoritarianism and Pro-Persian Cosmopolitanism, and Its Impacts on Ethno-Sectarian and Ethno-Linguistic Minorities.” In Ethnic Religious Minorities in Iran, edited by S. Behnaz Hosseini, 13–44. Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-1633-5_2.

Badrun, Badrun, Sujadi Sujadi, Idi Warsah, Imron Muttaqin, and Ruly Morganna. “Pancasila, Islam, and Harmonising Socio-Cultural Conflict in Indonesia.” Al-Jami’ah: Journal of Islamic Studies 61, no. 1 (November 19, 2023): 137–56. https://doi.org/10.14421/ajis.2023.611.137-156.

Bijana Kostadinov. “Constitutional Identity.” Iustinianus Primus Law Review 3, no. 4 (2012).

Bima, Muhammad Rinaldy, and John Tumba Jacob. “The Age Threshold for Presidential Nominations in the Perspective of Dignified Justice Theory: Why Is There a Mahkamah Keluarga Issue?” Jurnal IUS Kajian Hukum Dan Keadilan 11, no. 3 (December 26, 2023): 403–22. https://doi.org/10.29303/ius.v11i3.1301.

Brown, Nathan J. “Who Has Governed Egypt-Ruler, Regime, or State? Egypt’s Unrevolutionary 1971 Revolution.” In From the 1919 Revolution to the 2011 Arab Spring, by Uzi Rabi and Mira Tzoreff, 33–43, 1st ed. London: Routledge, 2024. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003351580-5.

Csáji, László Koppány. “Secularism and Ethnic Minorities: Comparative Case Studies on Ethnic, Religious, and Political Cognitions in Pakistani-Controlled Kashmir, Central Russia, Romania, and Northern Scandinavia.” Religions 14, no. 1 (January 13, 2023): 117. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel14010117.

Djawas, Mursyid, Abidin Nurdin, Muslim Zainuddin, Idham Idham, and Zahratul Idami. “Harmonization of State, Custom, and Islamic Law in Aceh: Perspective of Legal Pluralism.” Hasanuddin Law Review 10, no. 1 (May 1, 2024): 64. https://doi.org/10.20956/halrev.v10i1.4824.

Eddyono, Luthfi Widagdo. “Quo Vadis Pancasila Sebagai Norma Konstitusi Yang Tidak Dapat Diubah.” Jurnal Konstitusi 16, no. 3 (October 8, 2019): 585. https://doi.org/10.31078/jk1637.

———. “The Unamendable Articles of the 1945 Constitution.” Constitutional Review 2, no. 2 (February 6, 2017): 252. https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev225.

Farah Syah Rezah, Nurul Qamar. Metode Penelitian Hukum Doktrinal Dan Non-Doktrinal. Makassar: Social Politik Genius, 2020.

Febrian Nanda Putra Sukarna and Subelo Wiyono. “Implementation of Pancasila Values in Suppressing the Radicalism Movement.” Awang Long Law Review 6, no. 1 (November 30, 2023): 304–12. https://doi.org/10.56301/awl.v6i1.1034.

Frosini, Justin Orlando. Constitutional Preambles at a Crossroads Between Politics and Law. Università 70. Santarcangelo di Romagna: Maggioli, 2012.

Garry Jeffrey Jacobsohn. “Constitutional Identity.” The Review of Politics 68, no. 3 (2006).

Ghatas, Ishak Makram. “Muslim Minorities in Europe: A Case of Adaptations with Life with Neighbours in Brussels.” International Journal of Asian Christianity 5, no. 2 (August 30, 2022): 257–73. https://doi.org/10.1163/25424246-05020008.

Gouda, Moamen, and Jerg Gutmann. “Islamic Constitutions and Religious Minorities.” Public Choice 186, no. 3–4 (March 2021): 243–65. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11127-019-00748-7.

Hafiz Muhammad Ishaq and Muhammad Aman Ullah. “Rights of Non-Muslims in a Sharia and Its Application in Pakistan: قانون شریعت میں غیر مسلموں کے حقوق اور ان کا پاکستان میں اطلاق.” The Islamic Culture “As-Saqafat-Ul Islamia” الثقافة الإسلامية - Research Journal - Sheikh Zayed Islamic Centre, University of Karachi 47, no. 2 (December 30, 2022). https://doi.org/10.58352/tis.v47i2.873.

“Hanna Lerner, David Landau -- Andrew Arato -- Heinz Klug -- Cheryl Saunders -- Joel Colon-Rios -- Richard Albert -- Zach,” n.d.

Hapsoro, Fakhris Lutfianto, and Ismail Ismail. “Interpretasi Konstitusi Dalam Pengujian Konstitusionalitas Untuk Mewujudkan The Living Constitution.” Jambura Law Review 2, no. 2 (June 19, 2020): 139–60. https://doi.org/10.33756/jlr.v2i2.5644.

Hartono, Bambang. “The Value of Pancasila as an Ideological Based for the Development of the Legal System in Indonesia.” International Journal of Law and Politics Studies 6, no. 4 (August 1, 2024): 50–56. https://doi.org/10.32996/ijlps.2024.6.4.6.

Herlindah, Herlindah, Indah Dwi Qurbani, and Dorra Prisilia. “The Existence of Pancasila in Resolving Conflicts of Differing Views on Religious Rights in Indonesia.” Diponegoro Law Review 7, no. 2 (October 27, 2022): 212–29. https://doi.org/10.14710/dilrev.7.2.2022.212-229.

Husain, Sahin, Nasir Purkon Ayoub, and Mukhammadolim Hassmann. “Legal Pluralism in Contemporary Societies: Dynamics of Interaction between Islamic Law and Secular Civil Law.” SYARIAT: Akhwal Syaksiyah, Jinayah, Siyasah and Muamalah 1, no. 1 (April 30, 2024): 1–17. https://doi.org/10.35335/cfb3wk76.

Irwansyah, Irwansyah. Penelitian Hukum: Pilihan Metode & Praktik Penulisan Artikel. Yogyakarta: Mirra Buana Media, 2020.

Ishak, Nurfaika. “Religious Tolerance in the Constitution and Guarantees for the Protection of Human Rights.” Jurnal Scientia Indonesia 8, no. 1 (April 30, 2022): 53–70. https://doi.org/10.15294/jsi.v8i1.35953.

Jimly Asshiddiqie. Pancasila: Identitas Konstitusi Berbangsa Dan Bernegara. Jakarta: Rajawali Pers, 2020.

Karakuş, Muhammed, and Mehmet Akif Koç. “Social and Political Foundations of Constitutionalism in the Middle East: The First Constitutional Movements in Tunisia, Ottoman Turkey, Egypt, and Iran.” International Journal of Kurdish Studies 8, no. 2 (August 25, 2022): 150–74. https://doi.org/10.21600/ijoks.1103307.

Kolawole, Tobi Angel, and Helen Ting M. H. “Sharia Politics in Nigeria and Malaysia: Governance, Islamization and Human Rights.” Journal of Politics and Law 15, no. 3 (June 15, 2022): 25. https://doi.org/10.5539/jpl.v15n3p25.

M. Nggilu, Novendri, Dian Ekawaty Ismail, Tri Sulistyowati, and Mohamad Rivaldi Moha. “Constitutional Crisis: Intensifying Disobedience to the Decisions of the Indonesian Constitutional Court.” Revista Chilena de Derecho 50, no. 2 (October 23, 2023): 115–32. https://doi.org/10.7764/R.502.5.

Mahkamah Konstitusi. Naskah Komprehensif Perubahan Undang-Undang Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia Tahun 1945: Latar Belakang, Proses Dan Hasil Pembahasan 1999-2002, Buku III-Sendi-Sendi/Fundamental Negara. Jakarta: Sekretariat Jenderal dan Kepaniteraan Mahkamah Konstitusi RI, 2010.

———. Naskah Komprehensif Perubahan Undang-Undang Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia Tahun 1945: Latar Belakang, Proses Dan Hasil Pembahasan 1999-2002 (Buku VI-Kekuasaan Kehakiman). Jakarta: Sekretariat Jenderal dan Kepaniteraan Mahkamah Konstitusi RI, 2010.

Maranjaya, Abdul Kahar. “A Mechanism For Filling Regional Heads Positions In A Democratic Manner According To Pancasila Democracy’s Principle After The 1945 Constitution Amendments.” Syariah: Jurnal Hukum Dan Pemikiran 21, no. 2 (2021): 227–49. https://doi.org/10.18592/sjhp.v21i2.4870.

Maskanah, Ummi, Mohd Zakhiri Md Nor, and Aji Mulyana. “Application of the Principle of Justice in Non-Adjudicative Settlement of Banking Disputes from the Perspective of Islamic Law.” Jurisdictie: Jurnal Hukum Dan Syariah 15, no. 1 (July 9, 2024): 207–44. https://doi.org/10.18860/j.v15i1.25411.

Mohiuddin, Asif. “Islam, Religious Authority and The State: The Case of Egypt.” Asian Journal of Middle Eastern and Islamic Studies 16, no. 2 (April 3, 2022): 165–88. https://doi.org/10.1080/25765949.2022.2097730.

Neo, Jaclyn L. “Constitutional Identity as Discourse: Mis-Identity and Dis-Identity.” In Deciphering the Genome of Constitutionalism, edited by Ran Hirschl and Yaniv Roznai, 1st ed., 44–55. Cambridge University Press, 2024. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009473194.006.

Nggilu, Novendri, Mohamad Rivaldi Moha, Muhammad Ridho Sinaga, and Adelia Rachmaniar. “Judicial Review of Constitutional Amendments: Comparison Between India, Germany, Colombia, and the Relevancy with Indonesia.” Lex Scientia Law Review 8, no. 1 (September 22, 2024). https://doi.org/10.15294/lslr.v8i1.1901.

Nggilu, Novendri, Indra Perwira, and Ali Abdurahman. “Constitutionality Review of Indonesian Constitutional Amendments: History and Future.” Russian Law Journal 11, no. 2 (2023). https://doi.org/10.52783/rlj.v11i2.517.

Nolte, A. J. “The Indonesian Difference: Nationalism, Islam, and Pancasila Pluralism from State Formation to the Present.” In The Palgrave Handbook of Religion and State Volume II, edited by Shannon Holzer, 323–46. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-35609-4_15.

Omara, Andy. “Why Not Indonesia an Islamic State? Constitutional Debate Concerning Religion-State Relation in A Muslim Majority Country.” Samarah: Jurnal Hukum Keluarga Dan Hukum Islam 8, no. 1 (April 27, 2024): 421. https://doi.org/10.22373/sjhk.v8i1.15889.

Osredkar, Mari Jože, and Kasra Akhavan Azari. “Islamic Theocracy in Iran.” Edinost in dialog 77, no. 2 (2022). https://doi.org/10.34291/Edinost/77/02/Azari.

Polzin, Monika. “Constitutional Identity as a Constructed Reality and a Restless Soul.” German Law Journal 18, no. 7 (December 1, 2017): 1595–1616. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2071832200022458.

———. “Constitutional Identity, Unconstitutional Amendments and the Idea of Constituent Power: The Development of the Doctrine of Constitutional Identity in German Constitutional Law.” International Journal of Constitutional Law 14, no. 2 (April 2016): 411–38. https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/mow035.

PTE ÁJK, and Amna Hassan. “The Shariah Law in Pakistani Legal System and General Legal Status of Women in Pakistan.” DÍKÉ 4, no. 1 (September 1, 2020): 190–210. https://doi.org/10.15170/DIKE.2020.04.01.13.

Ra’ees, Wahabuddin and Kamal, Abdol Moghset Bani. “Human Rights of Religious and Ethnic Minorities in the Islamic Republic of Iran.” The Journal for Interdisciplinary Middle Eastern Studies, no. 4 (2019): 9–31. https://doi.org/10.26351/JIMES/4/1.

Rasyid, Usman, Novendri Mohamad Nggilu, Fence Wantu, Julisa Aprilia Kaluku, and Ahmad Ahmad. “Reformulation of the Authority of Judicial Commission: Safeguarding the Future of Indonesian Judicial Power.” Jambura Law Review 5, no. 2 (July 31, 2023): 386–413. https://doi.org/10.33756/jlr.v5i2.24239.

Rodiah Nur, Efa, and Fathul Mu’in. “Integration of Religious and Social Values in the Development of the Indonesian Constitution Era 5.0.” KnE Social Sciences, January 11, 2024. https://doi.org/10.18502/kss.v9i2.14962.

Rosenfeld, Michel, and András Sajó, eds. The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law. 1st ed. Oxford, U.K: Oxford University Press, 2012.

Roznai, Yaniv. Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments: The Limits of Amendment Powers. First published in paperback. Oxford Constitutional Theory. Oxford, United Kingdom New York, United States of America: Oxford University Press, 2019.

Roznai, Yaniv, and Letícia Regina Camargo Kreuz. “Conventionality Control and Amendment 95/2016: A Brazilian Case of Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendment.” Revista de Investigações Constitucionais 5, no. 2 (May 1, 2018): 35. https://doi.org/10.5380/rinc.v5i2.57577.

Samosir, Agustinus, Khalisah Hayatuddin, and Azizah Azizah. “Pancasila Values in Indonesian Legal System.” International Journal of Social Science and Human Research 7, no. 07 (July 27, 2024). https://doi.org/10.47191/ijsshr/v7-i07-105.

Saputri, Fitri Arianti. “The Position of Customary Law in the Legal System: An ExplorationRole, Challenges, and Integration in the Context of National Legal Development.” Journal of Adat Recht 1, no. 1 (May 27, 2024). https://doi.org/10.62872/esmxh108.

Sarifuzzaman, Khan. “The Role of Political Islam in Egyptian Democratic Experience.” Journal of Social and Political Sciences 2, no. 3 (September 30, 2019). https://doi.org/10.31014/aior.1991.02.03.92.

Satrio, Abdurrachman. “Restoring Indonesia’s (Un)Constitutional Constitution: Soepomo’s Authoritarian Constitution.” German Law Journal 24, no. 2 (March 2023): 402–16. https://doi.org/10.1017/glj.2023.16.

Schirrmacher, Christine. “The Sharia-Based Understanding of Religious Freedom and Women’s Rights in Conflict with the Secular Constitutional State.” Societas Dei: Jurnal Agama Dan Masyarakat 2, no. 2 (October 24, 2017): 366. https://doi.org/10.33550/sd.v2i2.22.

Sekretariat Negara Republik Indonesia. Himpunan Risalah Sidang-Sidang Dari Badan Penyelidik Usaha Persiapan Kemerdekaan Indonesia (PPKI) Tanggal 29 Mei 1945 – 16 Juli 1945, Dan Panitia Persiapan Kemerdekaan Indonesia (PPKI) Tanggal 18-19 Agustus 1945 Yang Berhubungan Dengan Penyusunan Undang-Undang Dasar 1945. Jakarta: Sekretariat Negara Republik Indonesia, 1959.

Sidahmed, Abdel Salam. Islamic Fundamentalism. Edited by Abdel Salam Sidahmed and Anoushiravan Ehteshami. 1st ed. Routledge, 2018. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429499593.

Subandi Al Marsudi. Pancasila Dan UUD 45 Dalam Paradigma Reformasi. Jakarta: Raja Grafindo, 2012.

Supriyadi, Aditya Prastian, Dwi Fidhayanti, Ramadhita Ramadhita, and Mohd Shahid bin Mohd Noh. “Green Sukuk in Indonesia: Unraveling Legal Frameworks for Sustainable Islamic Bonds.” El-Mashlahah 13, no. 2 (December 31, 2023): 151–80. https://doi.org/10.23971/el-mashlahah.v13i2.7372.

Surajiyo Surajiyo. “Tinjauan Epistemologi Terhadap Pancasila Sebagai Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia.” Ikra-ITH Humaniora: Jurnal Sosial Dan Humaniora 5, no. 3 (2021): 54–62.

Susi Dwi Harjanti. Interaksi Konstitusi Dan Politik: Kontekstualisasi Pemikiran Sri Soemantri. Bandung: Pusat Studi Kebijakan Negara, 2016.

Varol, Fatih. “Theocratic Democracy: The Social Construction of Religious and Secular Extremism.” Türkiye Ortadoğu Çalışmaları Dergisi 4, no. 2 (December 29, 2017): 188–91. https://doi.org/10.26513/tocd.355486.

Venter, Francois. “Utilizing Constitutional Values in Constitutional Comparison.” Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal 4, no. 1 (July 10, 2017): 19–41. https://doi.org/10.17159/1727-3781/2001/v4i1a2878.

Waseem, Mohammad. “Islamic Constitutionalism in Pakistan.” Arab Law Quarterly 38, no. 4 (June 20, 2024): 446–65. https://doi.org/10.1163/15730255-bja10165.

Wilson, Anita, Samina Saeed, and Aziz Ur Rahman. “Constitutional Rights of Religious Minorities in Pakistan.” Global Political Review V, no. I (March 30, 2020): 316–25. https://doi.org/10.31703/gpr.2020(V-I).34.

Yance Arizona, et.al. Pancasila Dalam Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi. Jakarta: Epistema Institu, 2014.

Yildirim, A. Kadir. The Politics of Religious Party Change: Islamist and Catholic Parties in Comparative Perspective. 1st ed. Cambridge University Press, 2023. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009170734.

Zahir, Azim. “Beyond Fixed Political Models of Religion–State Relations.” Religions 14, no. 3 (March 13, 2023): 384. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel14030384.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.18860/j-fsh.v16i2.29851

Copyright (c) 2024 Nggilu et al

Published By:

Shariah Faculty Universitas Islam Negeri Maulana Malik Ibrahim Malang

Gajayana Street 50 Malang, East Java, Indonesia

 


De Jure: Jurnal Hukum dan Syar'iah is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International