Comparative Evaluation of Boyle and Hull Trinomial Lattices for Employee Stock Option Valuation with Discrete Dividends: Convergence and Moneyness Analysis
Abstract
Employee stock option (ESO) valuation using trinomial lattice methods may behave differently depending on the chosen parameterization and the discrete representation of the strike price. This study compares Boyle-type and Hull-type trinomial parameterizations, constructed using first-order asymptotic transition probabilities, to approximate the value of a European-style employee stock option under the Management and Employee Stock Option Plan (MESOP) Phase III.A of an anonymized Indonesian publicly listed company (referred to as PT XXX Corporindo Tbk), incorporating a discrete dividend through the escrowed dividend approach. The Black–Scholes model serves as an analytical benchmark to assess convergence, moneyness, volatility sensitivity, and strike-price position relative to lattice nodes. We examine three strike-price conditions: Rp499 as the actual contract condition, Rp1,530 as the at-the-money condition, and Rp1,630 as the out-of-the-money condition. Historical volatility is estimated at 38.1825% from 237 daily closing-price observations. The results show convergence behavior depends on lattice resolution and moneyness. Boyle reaches the prescribed error tolerance at a lower lattice resolution than Hull for the at-the-money condition. In contrast, Hull does so at a lower resolution for the out-of-the-money condition. At the same time, both parameterizations satisfy the tolerance at the same resolution for the in-the-money condition. The strike-grid analysis further reveals oscillatory error patterns and variation in relative accuracy across strike prices, suggesting that the strike position relative to lattice nodes may contribute to numerical variation beyond broad moneyness classification. These findings indicate that neither parameterization is uniformly superior and that trinomial accuracy should be assessed jointly with lattice resolution, moneyness, and strike position.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
[1] P. P. Boyle. “Option Valuation Using a Three-Jump Process”. In: International Options Journal 3 (1986), pp. 7–12. URL: https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=%22Option+Valuation+Using+a+Three-Jump+Process%22.
[2] P. P. Boyle. “A Lattice Framework for Option Pricing with Two State Variables”. In: Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 23.1 (1988), pp. 1–12. doi: 10.2307/2331019.
[3] J. C. Hull. Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives. 8th ed. Boston, MA, USA: Prentice Hall, 2012. URL: https://openlibrary.org/books/OL25296152M/Options_futures_and_other_derivatives.
[4] F. Black and M. Scholes. “The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities”. In: Journal of Political Economy 81.3 (1973), pp. 637–654. doi: 10.1086/260062.
[5] S. E. Shreve. Stochastic Calculus for Finance II: Continuous-Time Models. New York, NY, USA: Springer, 2004. doi: 10.1007/978-0-387-22527-2.
[6] J.-Y. Wang, C.-J. Wang, T.-S. Dai, T.-C. Chen, L.-C. Liu, and L. Zhou. “Efficient and Robust Combinatorial Option Pricing Algorithms on the Trinomial Lattice for Polynomial and Barrier Options”. In: Mathematical Problems in Engineering 2022 (2022), p. 5843491. doi: 10.1155/2022/5843491.
[7] G. Leduc and K. Palmer. “The Convergence Rate of Option Prices in Trinomial Trees”. In: Risks 11.3 (2023), p. 52. doi: 10.3390/risks11030052.
[8] Y. Ratibenyakool and K. Neammanee. “Rate of Convergence of the Trinomial Formula to the Black–Scholes Formula”. In: Statistics & Probability Letters 213 (2024), p. 110167. doi: 10.1016/j.spl.2024.110167.
[9] G. Leduc. “The Boyle–Romberg Trinomial Tree, a Highly Efficient Method for Double Barrier Option Pricing”. In: Mathematics 12.7 (2024), p. 964. doi: 10.3390/math12070964.
[10] F. Agustina, N. Sumarti, and K. A. Sidarto. “Construction of the Bino-Trinomial Method Using the Fuzzy Set Approach for Option Pricing”. In: Journal of the Indonesian Mathematical Society 30.2 (2024), pp. 179–204. doi: 10.22342/jims.30.2.1775.179-204.
[11] J. Gnawali, W. B. Lindquist, and S. T. Rachev. “Hedging via Perpetual Derivatives: Trinomial Option Pricing and Implied Parameter Surface Analysis”. In: Journal of Risk and Financial Management 18.4 (2025), p. 192. doi: 10.3390/jrfm18040192.
[12] J. X. Wu and T. Wu. “Pricing Parisian and ParAsian Options by a Vectorized Binomial or Trinomial Tree”. In: Journal of Futures Markets 46.8 (2026), pp. 1380–1389. doi: 10.1002/fut.70110.
[13] P. A. K. Sholikha and R. Artiono. “Pemodelan Matematika Opsi Saham Karyawan Menggunakan Metode Trinomial Boyle (Mathematical Modeling of Employee Stock Options Using the Trinomial Boyle Method; in Indonesian)”. In: MATHunesa: Jurnal Ilmiah Matematika 11.2 (2023), pp. 122–127. doi: 10.26740/mathunesa.v11n2.p122-127.
[14] D. L. Fitroh and R. Artiono. “Model Matematika Penilaian Opsi Saham Karyawan Menggunakan Metode Pohon Binomial (Mathematical Model for Valuing Employee Stock Options Using the Binomial Tree Method; in Indonesian)”. In: MATHunesa: Jurnal Ilmiah Matematika 11.3 (2023), pp. 360–367. doi: 10.26740/mathunesa.v11n3.p360-367.
[15] N. H. Taufiqi and R. Artiono. “Pemodelan Matematika Opsi Saham Karyawan yang Mempertimbangkan Efek Dilusi (Mathematical Modeling of Employee Stock Options Considering the Dilution Effect; in Indonesian)”. In: MATHunesa: Jurnal Ilmiah Matematika 11.3 (2023), pp. 414–421. doi: 10.26740/mathunesa.v11n3.p414-421.
[16] D. C. Lesmana, R. T. A. Ramadhan, S. Nurjanah, and V. S. Dharmawan. “Pricing Employee Stock Option Using Trinomial Tree Method”. In: BAREKENG: Journal of Mathematics and Its Application 19.2 (2025), pp. 709–720. doi: 10.30598/barekengvol19iss2pp709-720.
[17] D. C. Lesmana, N. Christina, R. A. Kusuma, and S. S. Nabila. “Binary Option Pricing Using Lattice Method”. In: BAREKENG: Journal of Mathematics and Its Application 19.1 (2025), pp. 361–374. doi: 10.30598/barekengvol19iss1pp361-374.
[18] W. Wahyuni and D. Ekawati. “Perbandingan Harga Opsi Put Tipe Eropa Menggunakan Metode Binomial dan Trinomial (Comparison of European Put Option Prices Using Binomial and Trinomial Methods; in Indonesian)”. In: Jurnal Sains Matematika dan Statistika 10.1 (2024), pp. 85–94. doi: 10.24014/jsms.v10i1.20504.
[19] P. De Angelis, R. De Marchis, A. L. Martire, and E. Russo. “A Flexible Lattice Framework for Valuing Options on Assets Paying Discrete Dividends and Variable Annuities Embedding GMWB Riders”. In: Decisions in Economics and Finance 45 (2022), pp. 415–446. doi: 10.1007/s10203-022-00371-0.
[20] A. K. D. Maharani and E. Siswanah. “European Option Pricing Using Trinomial Method with Dividend”. In: Jurnal Matematika, Statistika dan Komputasi 22.2 (2026), pp. 291–300. doi: 10.20956/j.v22i2.46442.
[21] Y. Shan, H. Shu, X. Zhang, and H. Yi. “The Valuation of Options on Discrete Dividend-Paying Stocks”. In: Applied Economics Letters 31.12 (2024), pp. 1090–1095. doi: 10.1080/13504851.2023.2176431.
[22] M. G. Elgiffary and R. Artiono. “Numerical Pricing of Discrete-Dividend European Options: An Empirical Case Study”. In: CAUCHY: Jurnal Matematika Murni dan Aplikasi 11.1 (2026), pp. 724–735. doi: 10.18860/cauchy.v11i1.40995.
[23] K. Aretz, M.-T. Lin, and S.-H. Poon. “Moneyness, Underlying Asset Volatility, and the Cross-Section of Option Returns”. In: Review of Finance 27.1 (2023), pp. 289–323. doi: 10.1093/rof/rfac003.
[24] F. Liang, L. Du, and Z. Huang. “Option Pricing with Overnight and Intraday Volatility”. In: Journal of Futures Markets 43.11 (2023), pp. 1576–1614. doi: 10.1002/fut.22448.
[25] M. Ulrich, L. Zimmer, and C. Merbecks. “Implied Volatility Surfaces: A Comprehensive Analysis Using Half a Billion Option Prices”. In: Review of Derivatives Research 26 (2023), pp. 135–169. doi: 10.1007/s11147-023-09195-5.
[26] D. Tazkya, R. Oktavia, and I. Syahrini. “The Trinomial Tree Method in Pricing European Gold Option with Volatility Forecasting Using the GARCH (1,1) Model”. In: ZERO: Jurnal Sains, Matematika dan Terapan 9.1 (2025), pp. 277–288. doi: 10.30829/zero.v9i1.25455.
[27] M. Costabile, I. Massabò, E. Russo, and A. Staino. “A Lattice-Based Algorithm for Pricing Derivatives in a Fractional Brownian Motion Framework”. In: Annals of Finance 21 (2025), pp. 435–458. doi: 10.1007/s10436-025-00474-9.
[28] A. Jacquier. Numerical Methods in Finance. Lecture Notes, MSc in Mathematics and Finance, Department of Mathematics, Imperial College London. Spring Term 2016–2017, version of March 8, 2017. URL: https://wwwf.imperial.ac.uk/~ajacquie/IC_Num_Methods/IC_Num_Methods_Docs/NMImperial.pdf.
[29] J. H. Chan, M. Joshi, R. Tang, and C. Yang. “Trinomial or Binomial: Accelerating American Put Option Price on Trees”. In: Journal of Futures Markets 29.9 (2009), pp. 826–839. doi: 10.1002/fut.20389.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.18860/cauchy.v11i2.46440
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
Copyright (c) 2026 Maeva Wulandari

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Editorial Office
Mathematics Department,
Maulana Malik Ibrahim State Islamic University of Malang
Gajayana Street 50 Malang, East Java, Indonesia 65144
e-mail: cauchy@uin-malang.ac.id

CAUCHY: Jurnal Matematika Murni dan Aplikasi is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.







